After months of renovations at the old Catch /Papa Joe’s/Dockside restaurant on West Broadway in Port Jeff, a new and much improved restaurant called Schafer’s has opened up the upper level for lunch, diner and weekend entertainment. While they finish up and complete improvements downstairs, the upstairs is now open and guests are able to sample their American style menu , enjoy cocktails and get an idea of what is to come!.
One might think the upper deck lends itself to a casual dining experience with it’s open roof , wire tables and umbrellas but be prepared for an upscale, sophisticated experience. The menu is interesting “American Style” and features Small Plates, Sushi, Raw bar, Salads as well as Seafood, Lobster and Steak entrees. When you order also be prepared for an upscale presentation! There is a full bar upstairs, reasonable priced wine list and entertainment on the weekend. What is not to like? Nice job and well worth the wait!
Mussels & Andouille Small Plate at Schafer's Restaurant Port Jeff
- Where: Upper Level Schafer’s Restaurants
- What: Lunch, Diner & Entertainment
- Coming Soon: Fully renovated lower level!
Buyer Beware: Food was great, but customer service…not so much. We were greeted by our waiter asking if we would like regular or sparkling water. We requested sparkling thinking it was complimentary or a small $2.00 fee. As we started drinking our water, the bus boy came over and poured regular water in our glass. Still, not a big deal as we are not fussy. What really got us upset was when we got the bill and saw the charge for $28 for four WATERS! That was seven dollars for each glass of sparkling water. I approached the manager and told him that this was ridiculous unless there was gold in the water and the bus boy ruined the “sparkle” with the regular water anyway. After a lengthy argument, he agreed to refund me for two of the waters. WOW! Now I only paid $14 for four WATERS! If I knew I was going to be drinking seven dollar water, I would’ve ordered a margarita instead! Needless to say, I will not be returning. They definitely started off on the wrong foot! Shame on Shafers!
Oops! I can definitely recommend an Absolute and cranberry for .50 more!
I remember this place – it’s time to come back
Bring the family you should see the lobster and sushi at Schafers! Jeremy would be truly amazed!
is that you ,Dirk who used to be the bartender?
no – I was just a regular customer on a visit, sorry
I stopped for drinks with my wife on the upper deck of Schafer’s on Friday Aug 12, 2011 and I must say I was extremely impressed with the new renovations. It was a beautiful night and we were seated at the new mahogany bar, watching the game on 2 large flat screen TV’s and enjoying the fantastic view of Port Jefferson Harbor. With the roof retracted, the windows open and a northerly breeze, the night could not have been better. There is not a place other then Schafer’s, in the immediate north shore area, that boasts an outside bar with a water view. We had the mussels as an appetizer and shrimp caprese as a main course and they were both excellent. Afterwards we went down to watch the dueling pianos. No expense was spared with the renovations downstairs, which were too numerous to mention and must be seen to be appreciated. The piano show was a pleasant surprise. The performers got the crowd into the music, but it was not overbearing. Overall the evening was great and I can without hesitation recommend Schafer’s to anyone who is looking for fantastic food and a fun night out.